Brewers Keep Winning, Cubs Bullpen Turning Way Up (But They Still Need a Closer), and Other Cubs Bullets

The Brewers are so annoying. Even though the Cubs (16-9) are seven games over .500 and winners in 9 of their last 12 games, including a three-game sweep of the Astros, there’s Milwaukee (16-8) … just quietly sitting there a half-game higher in first place.

Didn’t we steal Craig Counsell to stop this nonsense?

  • I guess the difference this year is that they’ve been “earning it” in more obvious ways. It’s too early for this to be predictive, but just to give you a sense of how things have played out to date, the Brewers (+35) have the fourth highest run differential in baseball through their first 24 games. As a team, they’re slashing an incredible .264/.343/.421 (115 wRC+, 4th) overall, with William Contreras turning into an absolute monster: .365/.446/.573 (183 wRC+, 5HRs and 22 RBI already).
  • And while their rotation has been merely average, their bullpen has been lights out all year (2.73 ERA, 0.8 WAR). The Cubs bullpen, by contrast: 3.71 ERA and -0.4 WAR. But wait a minute … it doesn’t quite feel that way lately, right?
  • As pointed out by Aldo Soto, since the end of the Padres series, the Cubs bullpen has actually been lights out in terms of results: 1.93 ERA (4th best) over 51.1 IP (7th most). And it feels like a lot of that is due to some recent moves in the ‘pen, both transactionally and in terms of roles. For example, none of Keegan Thompson (7.0 scoreless innings), Ben Brown (3.0 scoreless innings), or Hayden Wesneski (6.1 scoreless innings) were part of the opening day bullpen, but all three have all made significant contributions there lately. Meanwhile, Yency Almonte (5.0 scoreless innings) has been deployed more aggressively and has been responding really well.
  • The Cubs also moved Adbert Alzolay out of their closers role, and he’s responded with two scoreless, hitless, walk-less appearances against Miami and Houston, with just a HBP to his name. And frankly, he can’t come back (to the best version of himself) soon enough. Because even though Hector Neris has converted back-to-back saves, you cannot watch these games and think he’s the answer as closer. His command is off, his velocity remains down, and he isn’t fooling batters at ALL. That’s why we’re seeing all these long plate appearances – foul ball after foul ball after foul ball … and then a walk.
  • Looking under the hood, I can see that opposing batters have made contact on a staggering 96.9% of pitches Neris has thrown in the zone this season, which is tied for the 9th highest in MLB. And he’s starting behind the count more than all but two relievers (3rd lowest first-pitch strike rate). With all that plus more walks (9) than strikeouts (8), the traffic is mounting — a 1.78 WHIP on the year (29th worst among all 208 qualified relievers). It’s not a good idea to keep him in the closer’s role.
  • But I also know there still isn’t really an obvious answer. We’ve gone over this before, but the Cubs most dependable reliever right now, Mark Leiter Jr., is probably still best served being deployed at any high-leverage point in the game, and otherwise saved for huge moments against left-handed batters. Everyone else is either not there right now (Alzolay, Neris), not a closer (Brewer, Almonte, Little), or is more of a long-man (Wesneski, Thompson). Brown has the stuff, but might actually be in the rotation(?) still. And Thompson could be that guy, but I don’t know if we’re quite there yet.
  • As for Hayden Wesneski … we’ll have more on him later today. He’s been a stud. Not a solution to closer, but so so good.
  • The Cubs two most valuable position players by WAR this season? Nico Hoerner (125 wRC+, 0.9 WAR) and Mike Tauchman (164 wRC+, 0.8 WAR). One day after homering twice, Tauchman reached base four times yesterday and is now slashing .298/.437/.491 for the season. He has the 8th highest OBP in MLB among qualified hitters. I have no idea how he’s doing it, but with Seiya Suzuki and Cody Bellinger both out, he picked a great time to be great.
  • Pete Crow-Armstrong met the fan who caught his first big league hit and home run after the game, signing his game-used bat in a postgame meet and swap:
  • I case you missed it, the Chicago Bears drafted Quarterback Caleb Williams first overall last night. And you can already get his gear. He’ll wear No. 18 and hopefully become the first good Bears quarterback, like … ever.
  • written by

    Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

    more cubs news

    Chicago Cubs Lineup: Hello, Cody!

    CUBS LINEUP — With Dylan Cease scheduled to pitch for the Padres in the finale tomorrow, the Cubs are really going to want to take this game tonight. Fortunately, they have Shota Imanaga on the mound ... and CODY BELLINGER...

    Marcus Semien is a Triple Shy of the Cycle … in the 2nd Inning!

    Well, have yourself a day, Marcus Semien. The Rangers infielder is 3-3 with a home run, double, single, four RBI, and a run scored today against the Oakland Athletics, and they're only in the second inning! Semien led the game...

    Thinking About the Cubs Lineup AFTER Cody Bellinger and Seiya Suzuki Return

    UPDATE: Cody Bellinger is officially back with the Chicago Cubs, having been called up after publication of this article. Original post follows. *** According to Taylor McGregor on last night's broadcast, we are maybe a day away from Cody Bellinger...

    CODY BELLINGER IS BACK (Plus Several Other Cubs Roster Moves and Injury Updates)

    No point in burying the lede! The Chicago Cubs center fielder, Cody Bellinger, is officially back with the team just TWO WEEKS after fracturing multiple ribs on a collision with the center field wall. I'd say that's as "best case...

    Keegan Thompson is at Wrigley Field, So Apparently a Move is Coming

    Sam Bernero has an eagle-eye and a steady camera, so when there are players newly in town around Wrigley Field, she is frequently the first person to have it. So it is today, with the return of Keegan Thompson to...

    MLBits: Surprising AL Central, Wheeler Rolls, Shōta’s Fastball, Buehler’s Back, More

    One of baseball's biggest surprises through six weeks? The AL Central has been pretty good this season. Plus, Walker Buehler returns to a major league mound after 22 months, Shōta Imanaga's four-seamer draws national attention, and more in today's MLB...

    The Starkly Contrasted Cubs Rotation and Cubs Bullpen

    It's quite a jarring polarity right now between the Chicago Cubs' starting pitchers on the one hand, and the Chicago Cubs' relief pitchers on the other hand. The starters, obviously, have been unbelievably good. The relievers, by contrast, have struggled...

    Cubs Farm Report | May 7, 2024: Top 25 Prospect Stock Report

    The Chicago Cubs minor league affiliates were off on Monday, so it's time to take stock of some recent hot (and not-so-hot) performers inside the Cubs Top 25 prospects down on the farm in today's Cubs Farm Report. Cubs Farm...

    Happ and Swanson Struggling, PCA and Mervis Headed in Different Directions, Rojas, and Other Cubs Bullets

    Well, my friends, we made it. Almost exactly one month after Brett's back surgery put him on the shelf, he's ready to come back full-time. I'm still your man today for bullets and game coverage, but I'll be handing the...

    Christopher Morel is Scorching Hot Again, Including Career Homer Number 50

    For the 5th time in his last 8 games, Christopher Morel homered last night. It was a particularly special one for the 24-year-old third baseman, as it was Morel's 50th career home run: https://twitter.com/WatchMarquee/status/1787657566895444414 https://twitter.com/WatchMarquee/status/1787829739496829379 Although the dinger did not...

    Latest News

    Marcus Semien is a Triple Shy of the Cycle … in the 2nd Inning!

    Well, have yourself a day, Marcus Semien. The Rangers infielder is 3-3 with a home run, double, single, four RBI, and a run scored today against the Oakland Athletics, and they're only in the second inning! Semien led the game...

    CODY BELLINGER IS BACK (Plus Several Other Cubs Roster Moves and Injury Updates)

    No point in burying the lede! The Chicago Cubs center fielder, Cody Bellinger, is officially back with the team just TWO WEEKS after fracturing multiple ribs on a collision with the center field wall. I'd say that's as "best case...

    Chicago Cubs Lineup: Hello, Cody!

    CUBS LINEUP — With Dylan Cease scheduled to pitch for the Padres in the finale tomorrow, the Cubs are really going to want to take this game tonight. Fortunately, they have Shota Imanaga on the mound ... and CODY BELLINGER...

    2024 MLB Futures Odds: Who’s Winning the AL MVP Race?

    As the Major League Baseball season progresses, MLB Futures odds begin to come into focus. The race for the American League (AL) Most Valuable Player (MVP) award heats up, capturing the attention of fans and bettors alike. With several standout...

    Keegan Thompson is at Wrigley Field, So Apparently a Move is Coming

    Sam Bernero has an eagle-eye and a steady camera, so when there are players newly in town around Wrigley Field, she is frequently the first person to have it. So it is today, with the return of Keegan Thompson to...

    Rookie of the Year 2024 Odds Update and Betting Advice: Colton Cowser, Shōta Imanaga Imanaga Lead the Way

    The MLB season is heating up, and players are already separating themselves from the pack. Who is the current favorite to win the Rookie of the Year? Who has an excellent chance to make a run at the award? Take...

    Thinking About the Cubs Lineup AFTER Cody Bellinger and Seiya Suzuki Return

    UPDATE: Cody Bellinger is officially back with the Chicago Cubs, having been called up after publication of this article. Original post follows. *** According to Taylor McGregor on last night's broadcast, we are maybe a day away from Cody Bellinger...

    AL Cy Young 2024 Odds Update and Betting Advice: Corbin Burnes is the Favorite, But Seattle’s Bryce Miller is an Interesting Case

    The MLB season is heating up, and players are already separating themselves from the pack. Who is the current favorite to win the AL Cy Young? Who has an excellent chance to make a run at the award? Take a...

    Blackhawks Sign Lukas Reichel to Two-Year Deal

    On Tuesday afternoon, just hours before the 2024 NHL Draft Lottery, the Chicago Blackhawks announced the team has signed forward Lukas Reichel to a two-year contract that carries a $1.2 million cap hit. https://twitter.com/NHLBlackhawks/status/1787905424173449489 Reichel, 21, is coming off a...

    2024 Wells Fargo Championship Odds, History, & Picks: Bet Corey Conners & Max Homa

    Who Will Take Home the Trophy? A Look at the 2024 Wells Fargo Championship Odds The Wells Fargo Championship is upon us, and with it comes the thrill of competition and the chance to see some of the world's best...

    more cubs news