Obsessive Cody Bellinger Watch: What is “Likely,” Angels Talking to Boras, PCA, More

Given that I’ve been obsessing over Cody Bellinger’s market for months now, this turned into an Obsessive Watch without me even realizing it.

Some of the latest on Bellinger …

  • If you needed another presumptive statement about the Cubs and Bellinger, look no further than the latest from Sahadev Sharma and Patrick Mooney at The Athletic, which opens with, “Even if the Chicago Cubs re-sign Cody Bellinger — an outcome that seems likely but is hardly guaranteed — a big part of this year will be creating opportunities for young talent.” Seems likely.
  • Now, that article is about young players emerging on the big league team this year (and it’s a great read!), so please understand this is not about reporting new information. Instead, it’s about a couple plugged-in local beats who are operating off of a baseline where Cody Bellinger returning to the Cubs this offseason “seems likely.” Not a sure thing. Not guaranteed. But likely.
  • One thing I have trouble reconciling: if everyone is so sure the Cubs are going to eventually get Bellinger, then what does that say about his eventual price tag? Because a world where the Cubs land him is a world where they got their price, not the other way around. So is Bellinger – and Scott Boras – really going to take a deal that is surprisingly low? Will it come to that? I just don’t see Jed Hoyer giving Bellinger a monster contract, given the performance risks (the down years due to injury and the contact quality questions) and the future positional overlaps (Bellinger is arguably worth a monster contract only as long as he stays in center field). So, if you asked all the folks predicting he lands with the Cubs, are they also predicting Bellinger winds up with a disappointing contract? Because that’s the only way I can square that circle.
  • We’ve said since literally day one of the offseason that (1) if Bellinger doesn’t get a monster contract offer, he’s coming back to the Cubs; and, (2) if Bellinger does get a monster contract offer, it won’t be from the Cubs. This all continues to track in my mind, but butts up against the idea that number 1 is more likely to happen than number 2.
  • Speaking of which, you know what team kinda scares me on Bellinger? A team that might do something crazy? The Angels. It’s been the Arte Moreno playbook for years now: find a star player, hone in on him regardless of how well he projects or fits with the roster, and then wildly overpay to get the deal done. If Moreno decides Bellinger is sufficiently star-like in Southern California, particularly on the heels of losing Shohei Ohtani to the crosstown Dodgers, it’s very easy to see him directing GM Perry Minasian to get a Bellinger deal done no matter what. These kinds of decisions aren’t always rational.
  • And this isn’t entirely out of the blue, as the Angels have reportedly had interest in Bellinger most of this offseason, even if they – like everyone else – have hesitated on the $200+ million price tag so far. In a recent podcast, David Vassegh of Dodger Talk reported that the Angels have been talking to Scott Boras about Bellinger. Just a ploy by Boras to get that word out there? Maybe. But it also might be a situation where Boras is trying to take the matter straight to Moreno. Vassegh speculated that the longer this goes on – which may be into Spring Training – the less the chances are the Cubs retain Bellinger, though I’ll disagree with him on that part. Longer is definitely better for the Cubs, as painful as the waiting has become.
  • Speaking of which, here is perhaps the Cubs trying to put out there that they don’t HAVE to have Bellinger, since they have Pete Crow-Armstrong waiting in the wings:
  • Here’s what I believe about the Cubs, PCA, and Cody Bellinger: long-term, the Cubs do believe PCA is going to be the center fielder of the future. Shorter-term, though, I don’t think they want to assume he’s going to be ready to be the starter for all of 2024. To that end, and because of his lefty power, I think the Cubs extremely want Bellinger back for 2024. The question is how much beyond 2024 do they accept, and figure they can coordinate later, in order to get Bellinger now.
  • Jon Heyman says Cody Bellinger remains the most logical fit for the Cubs, and vice versa, but Matt Chapman is an alternative. The Giants may not be hot on Bellinger after the Jung-Hoo Lee addition (which is an interesting comment from Heyman, who often has a lot to say about Boras clients that is helpful to their case), but the Angels like him.
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 10, Phillies 2 – July 4, 2024

    A blowout win! The Cubs are still allowed to do that, it turns out! Ian Happ is clearly an American patriot, because the dude loves having big games on the Fourth of July. You may remember last year's installment where...

    Ian Happ Celebrates the Fourth of July By Homering from Both Sides of the Plate

    Hopefully you're watching the rare enjoyable Chicago Cubs game on this Fourth of July, as the team has built a healthy lead over the Phillies, primarily on the strength of TWO three-run Ian Happ homers. One from each side of...

    Chicago Cubs Lineup: Bote and Wisdom In

    CUBS LINEUP — We can't be consumed by our petty rivalries anymore. We will be united in our common passion. Perhaps it's fate that today is the Fourth of July, and once again, we will be fighting for our pride,...

    A Nice Night for PCA, Falling Way Out of It, Bad Injury News, All-Stars, and Other Cubs Bullets

    There is rain in the forecast all day and night around here today, imperiling the Fourth of July parade, the cookout, and the fireworks. Mother Nature being less than patriotic today ... At 13.0 games out, the Cubs are actually...

    Enhanced Box Score: Phillies 5, Cubs 3 – July 3, 2024

    The losing continues. Decisions become easier by the day. That might be the only positive I can take away. Shōta Imanaga pitched well enough tonight - well, I should say well enough if he were supported by a decent offense...

    Chicago Cubs Lineup: I’ve Seen This One Before

    CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs offense couldn't manage much of anything until the 9th inning last night, which is nothing new for this group. Unfortunately, today, they have the tough task of facing Zack Wheeler. Let's see what this Cubs...

    Craig Counsell Would Like to See the Cubs Make Good Decisions, Rather Than Bad Decisions, Because Good Decisions Are Good

    Chicago Cubs manager Craig Counsell was on 670 The Score today, and he was asked about what is likely to be the most obvious hot topic for the next few weeks: will the Cubs be buying or selling at the...

    Award Wins for a Couple Cubs Prospects: Triantos and Suriel

    A couple Chicago Cubs prospects have received league honors for their scorching hot weeks. James Triantos, who is on the cusp of being considered a consensus top-100 prospect, raked his way to Southern League Player of the Week: "Tennessee Smokies...

    Why Cody Bellinger May Not Generate a Huge Trade Return Even If He Heats Up

    There is a video clip floating around today of Steve Phillips, opining on Cody Bellinger's trade value on MLB Network. If you haven't seen it: https://twitter.com/MLBNetwork/status/1808549766395220046 Primarily, I will say that I agree that a number of teams would probably...

    Cubs Injury Notes: So Many Players to Update

    A whole lotta injured Cubs players means a whole lotta injury updates can drop at the same time ... Yency Almonte (shoulder strain): This has been a challenging injury situation, as it seemed like there were times when he was...

    Latest News

    Today’s Copa America 2024 Predictions, Picks and Odds – Friday, July 5

    There is one game on Friday's 2024 Copa America schedule, so let's take a look at the betting odds for this match.Looking for what you need to know in terms of the betting odds for today's action in the Copa...

    Mariners vs. Blue Jays: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 5

    A series opener between the Seattle Mariners (48-41) and Toronto Blue Jays (39-48) is scheduled for Friday at 9:40 PM ET, at T-Mobile Park.Want to see who's in and who's out for the Mariners and the Blue Jays? Keep scrolling...

    Orioles vs. Athletics: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 5

    The Baltimore Orioles (55-32) will visit the Oakland Athletics (33-56), Friday at 9:40 PM ET, in the first of a three-game series.Looking to see who's in and who's out for the Orioles and the Athletics? Continue scrolling for full injury...

    Twins vs. Astros: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 5

    On Friday, a series opener is on the schedule, with the Minnesota Twins (49-38) hosting the Houston Astros (45-42) at 8:10 PM ET.Curious about who's in and who's out for the Twins and the Astros? Read on to see complete...

    Royals vs. Rockies: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 5

    At Coors Field on Friday, the Colorado Rockies (30-57) begin a three-game series versus the Kansas City Royals (48-41), at 8:10 PM ET.Want to see who's playing for the Royals and the Rockies? Continue reading to see full injury reports...

    Rangers vs. Rays: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 5

    At Globe Life Field on Friday, the Tampa Bay Rays (44-43) open a three-game series versus the Texas Rangers (39-48), at 8:05 PM ET.Hoping to find out who's in and who's out for the Rangers and the Rays? Keep scrolling...

    Padres vs. Diamondbacks: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 5

    On Friday, a matchup of NL West rivals is on the docket, with the Arizona Diamondbacks (43-44) visiting the San Diego Padres (48-43) at 9:40 PM ET.Hoping to find out who's playing for the Padres and the Diamondbacks? Read on...

    Dodgers vs. Brewers: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 5

    Two teams leading their divisions -- the Los Angeles Dodgers (NL West) and the Milwaukee Brewers (NL Central) -- meet on Friday at 10:10 PM ET, at Dodger Stadium.Want to see who's playing for the Dodgers and the Brewers? Keep...

    Cubs vs. Angels Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Friday, July 5, 2024

    After a four-hit game in a win over the Phillies, Ian Happ leads the Chicago Cubs (40-48) as -197 favorites against the Los Angeles Angels (36-50). Action gets underway from Wrigley Field at 2:20 PM ET on Friday, live on...

    Storm vs Sky: Best Bets, Player Props & Computer Picks – July 5

    The Seattle Storm (13-6) will look to extend a four-game winning stretch when hosting the Chicago Sky (7-11) on Friday, July 5, 2024 at Climate Pledge Arena. This matchup is at 10:00 PM ET.Dig into the best bets available (based...

    more cubs news